The summer between high school graduation and college move-in day gave my relationship with Henry a metabolism boost. It evolved faster. We saw each other more. We fought more. We texted more. I upset him more. Our mental health struggles intensified. Our hope for the future grew despite it all. It was a summer of contradictions, but the uniquely electric summer between high school and college, I assumed, was always fraught with tension.
Graduation night felt surreal. The people you’ve grown up with are about to scatter into the wind, a puzzle that will never again be put back together. I was graduating with people I’d been in Girl Scouts with, people I’d played soccer and basketball and tennis with. Arizona had been my home since I was six years old. I got to sit by Steven Clements and Austen Cooley, our last names having been close in the alphabet since the third grade, where we’d first become best friends.
At the end of the momentous night, when the photographs and flowers and celebrations were done, when I lie in my bed, a graduated senior, the emotion that stuck out the most was surprise. I was surprised that Henry wasn’t mad at me. It was just the type of night where things usually seemed to go wrong for him.
Phew, I thought. We’d gotten through the evening unscathed.
* * *
Four days before high school graduation, on 5/24/14, Henry’s friend Angelo Tweeted, “Any single ladies hit up @Henry he’s cute.”
Ugh. I screenshotted it. Henry and I agreed that his friends were really immature, and that they didn’t take our relationship seriously, which sucked. We consoled each other. It was real to us.
* * *
That May, though, I was starting to crack. For the first time, I had to do some extra credit just to keep my A in Spanish, and I didn’t even bother taking the AP Spanish test. Although a small drift, it felt totally unlike me. I texted through all my classes. I’d been staying up late talking to Henry so many days in a row; exhaustion was the new normal. Senior year had its highlights, but I’d been running myself into the ground.
I was feeling so sad, so tired, had become so consumed by my stupid little cell phone and our up-and-down virtual love story, that one day, after Henry and I had a fight (I can’t even remember why now), I got into the shower, and I picked up my razor blade.
I had only ever tried cutting one other time, at the end of my junior year. I tried telling myself that Henry wasn’t causing my mental health problems because I’d felt depressed once before I even knew him. It was at our girls’ tennis end of season party almost a year before, and everyone was laughing and playing games, and I faked my smile in the group picture, and came home feeling empty inside.
Cutting really wasn’t for me — in fact, it frightened me — so I hadn’t tried it again. But I’d definitely felt my happiness come in waves, and like waves, retreat just as quickly. Sometimes I felt extreme pain that tears couldn’t resolve, or even a cold numbness, like I couldn’t tap into or be touched by the joy around me.
Earlier that year, my mom had found suicidal poetry in my bedside table. She made me see a therapist, but after half-assing the consult, I told my mom I had no interest in going back. Therapy is cool now; your mom making you go to therapy in high school was not cool.
Some of these feelings probably came from being a teenager: it’s hormonal agony. Some feelings came straight from the internet — the idea of cutting was not an original one, but something I’d come across in the media and online. Tumblr, for all its fanart and film photography, also had its dark corners and romanticization of mental health problems. How much of what I was feeling was true sadness and how much was learned or performative sadness, I wasn’t sure. Maybe it was a form of attention-seeking. Maybe I just needed sleep. I read that smart people were often more sad, which felt true. Henry was sad sometimes.
That day, after the first, very small cut in the shower, I felt like a bucket of ice water had been dropped over my head. RACHEL WAKE UP. This was not okay. What was I doing?! I threw the razor into the trash can immediately. Scared of myself, though somehow also certain I didn’t really want to harm myself, I got out of the shower, wrapped myself in a towel, went into my room, and asked Henry to call me — even though he’d been the one who first upset me.
I told him what I’d done, and I’d tried not to make it seem like it was his fault or directly connected to tour relationship. He related to my depressed feelings; in fact, he related more than I had initially realized. I learned that he was hurting himself, too. To what extent, how often, how serious, I didn’t know. But now, I worried about him.
Together, we seemed to make each other’s mental health worse. But we kept telling each other that the other person made us happier than we’d ever been.
I couldn’t figure out, at eighteen, how both could be true.
* * *
Now that he’d visited for spring break, my parents had no ground to stop me from going to Wisconsin. It was the summer of love, the summer of freedom, after all. The tangibility of our relationship — spending real money to get on real airplanes to visit each other in person — reassured me of how serious we were.
I flew to visit him in June, both of us now green high school grads. It was my turn to see his hometown. I sat inside the ice cream shop he worked at along the river while he flipped vinyls. He cooked a vegetarian dinner for me even though he ate meat. I got to know his parents, going out on a breakfast date with his mom while he worked. She didn’t seem nearly as mean as he’d portrayed her. We did crosswords together, got cupcakes, walked his dogs through fountains downtown. We showered together in his tiny bathroom, and I felt his soapy hands move smoothly all over my body; we didn’t have sex, but we continued to make our way around the bases. There was a picnic under a waterfall for crying out loud. I thought, God, this is perfect. I remember driving around country roads, my first time in rolling farm country, listening to the Book of Mormon soundtrack, and feeling like I was in a movie.
Mysteriously absent for the entire visit were his friends. In Arizona, I’d practically had a parade of people I wanted him to meet. But the two of us just spent our time in Wisconsin deliriously together — and mostly alone. I knew many of his friends’ names; he told me about them. Tony. Leah. Angelo. I knew that some girl had had to be his escort at his senior talent show, but it was just a friend; I knew he’d had to give his football jersey to a girl in the fall for Homecoming, but he’d wished it was me. Angelo had snatched Henry’s phone once and sent me dirty messages on Snapchat, asking about nudes and Henry’s “loads.” But while I was there, instead of showing me off and brandishing me on his arm, he kept me all to himself. He doesn’t want to waste a single minute of our alone time together, I figured. And some of those guys are lewd morons anyway. Henry didn’t seem all that emotional about leaving this small town behind. But it was a little weird to not meet anyone besides his parents and his grandma.
On one of our drives, a girl named Carly called him. I saw her name come up on his phone, and then he turned it over. His phone buzzed, and then buzzed again. She called him multiple times.
“A crazy ex-girlfriend,” he told me. And I believed him. If I was in her position, if I’d lost someone as smart and funny and clever and sweet as Henry, I’d probably go crazy, too.
* * *
That summer, between our visits, Henry’s aunts treated him to a special cycling event, an annual weeklong bike ride across the state of Iowa. Due to the nature of the ride, his ability to communicate was suddenly compromised.
It was the first time our usual 24/7 communication was disrupted. With little time, cell phone signal, or charging opportunities, he could only talk a few minutes a day. One of the first days of the ride, I missed a call from him. This was unacceptable. Didn’t I know how important I was to him? Didn’t I know what those five little minutes would mean to him? Couldn’t I just stay near my phone so I wouldn’t miss his call? Was that really so hard?
I stopped making plans. Instead of keeping busy, I found myself staring at the ceiling, missing my friends, just to make sure I would be there for the call. This just didn’t feel like me. Why did I have to give up whole days of summer vacation to be glued to my phone? Especially when he was busy anyway? Sure, I could’ve gone somewhere and kept my phone on loud (I already had a special ringtone for Henry), but the anxiety would’ve eaten at me. The divided attention would have ruined the hang. What if the battery got low? What if the service was bad? What if the coffee shop was too loud? What if he found out I was in someone else’s company during his five precious minutes?
Something was dawning on me, though. Something was trickling in. This was odd behavior. This wasn’t really me. I hated wasting away in my house on summer vacation. It was getting more difficult to come up with excuses for his behavior or mine.
***
Later that summer, around late July, my best friend Hailey invited me to a big graduation lunch with her family. Dress up, she’d instructed, which was unusual of her. She was going to be picking me up.
I wore a white dress, curled my hair like on graduation, slipped on heels, and put on mascara. Like every day in the eleven months Henry and I had been dating, I’d been texting him since I woke up. Henry had told me he was going on a solo bike-packing trip, where he’d be camping overnight. I actually thought this was really badass. He continued going in and out of service, but we kept texting when we could. In fact, I was a little worried about him, and I was surprised that he was able to text so much while biking, actually.
As the hour for Hailey’s lunch drew nearer and I was making final adjustments in the bathroom, Henry disclosed that he was lost on his trail. He said he was looking for his way home. Fuck. I texted him that I could cancel my plans with Hailey if he needed me. Maybe I could look up a map or something. I sat down on the lip of the bathtub, pausing. Where are you? I thumbed out. He implored that I not cancel and that he would be fine, which was unusual of him. Normally he wanted as much bandwidth as I was able to give. I was really starting to worry — I’d have to make up some excuse to dip out of Hailey’s thing when—
The doorbell rang, “Coming!” I called. I ran down the stairs, grabbed my wallet and swung the tall front door open.
Holy shit.
Not Hailey, but Henry stood in my entryway in dress pants and a black tie and a gray vest, holding a bouquet of white roses. My favorite flower. He’d surprised me from 2,000 miles away. My wallet fell to the ground and I threw my arms around his neck. My mom snapped pictures; she’d clearly been in on it, which surprised me — I couldn’t believe he’d been texting my mom and planning this whole thing.
I thought to myself, thank god I told him the truth about Hailey’s graduation lunch. I hadn’t been lying to Henry all the time. But I’d had to duck and hide a few times, had told him I was available even though I was watching a movie with my family or told him I was hanging out with friends but left out the guys’ names. Now here he was, in the flesh, and I felt extremely relieved that I’d told him exactly what I was doing that day, full honesty, because of course, those plans were made up, and he was in on them. Oh god.
He even filmed himself walking around my neighborhood, recording a message to me, about how I had no idea he was coming, how excited he was to surprise me, how nervous he was feeling. It clicked, the whole biking ruse. He was “lost.” He was on his way “home.”
I was his home. Cue melting. Melting with that side dish of and thank God I told him the truth.
It was the most romantic surprise, which led into yet another several days of whimsical teenage love while he stayed at my house in Chandler with my family.
One night, I took him to a swing dance hall. They had a photographer there that night who captured us smiling, sheer joy on our sweating faces as we circled around and around on the dance floor. We were over the moon; we’d danced so hard during the polka that we’d fallen to the floor. That night as I drove us home, feeling incredibly in love, we stopped at a gas station and hand in hand, we stood proudly at the cash register and bought condoms.
It was telling to me that he didn’t bring any condoms from Wisconsin. A guy expecting sex would have brought some, had one in his wallet, right? The guy who cheats on you, who’s having sex all over the place, he’s got a condom. But Henry? Henry was waiting for me to be ready, despite our distance, despite the expectation we’d set that we would have sex for the first time on this trip. His patience was so endearing.
Ever since he’d first visited over spring break, the topic of sex came up more. Quite a lot more, actually. He asked what we would be doing if we were together right now? We had tried some virtual sexy things, sometimes over Skype, but mostly just through texting long, sultry paragraphs. It was a strange place for my sexual awakening to take place. In fact, I taught myself how to pleasure myself just so I’d be ready in case he wanted to try phone stuff. He’d asked if I had any fantasies, but I had zero. He had quite a few. I was still a virgin; vanilla missionary would do. Sometimes, we would sext and it would be fun; other times, he’d want to sext and I was, like, watching a movie with my family, feeling anything but sexy as I texted through the whole film, feeling awkward that someone might see what was on my phone.
When we floated the idea of having sex this trip, I felt totally ready. This was our third visit after all. We got home from the dance hall, curled up together in the guest bedroom, partially lit from the street lamps. He opened the condom and thankfully knew what he was doing, because I’d never touched one before. We tried to have sex, but knowing little of foreplay or how much pain was ‘normal,’ it didn’t work, as it doesn’t for some people their first time. I was probably too nervous, especially having heard from people that the first time hurts. It made me impenetrable. We physically couldn’t make sex happen, and eventually we gave up. I felt like my body wasn’t working how it was supposed to. I couldn’t ‘make love’ to the person I loved. I whispered this to him, tears stinging my eyes. I felt like a failure. Henry told me we had made love anyway, that we made love every time we were together.
He held me so tightly that night, and he didn’t push it any further.
* * *
Like his last visit to Arizona, his surprise visit that July was half picture-perfect moments, half… not so perfect. One morning, when he couldn’t sleep after I’d already snuck back to my room, he encouraged me to leave the house with him. This felt like sneaking out to me, and I’d never done that before and had never wanted to. I knew that my parents would be more forgiving than Henry would be, so I left with him on a walk outside at 5:00 am. I texted my parents that I was sorry, that we were just heading out for an early start, and I’d be back soon. I did not want to leave the house that morning at all. I did anyway.
Another day, we went tubing down the Salt River. We put on our bathing suits, rented our tubes, tied them off with bedsheets, and ate snacks as we talked and basked in the sun. On the drive home, he chose to ride passenger in only his boxers, and at other points, totally naked. I myself was fully clothed. I don’t know what made him do it. Was it the thrill of breaking a social norm? Did he expect me to touch him while I was driving? He even stayed in the car, half-naked, while I went into a restaurant to get us lunch. It was a bizarre drive home. It didn’t feel sexual in nature, really. It just felt… deviant. I didn’t know where to look as my Honda ate up the blistering pavement on the five-lane freeways of Phoenix in broad daylight. It was exhilarating to break the rules, in a way. But I still couldn’t understand… why? And I knew I didn’t want to get in trouble, if you could even get in trouble for that kind of thing. I guess the whole thing just sort of put me on edge. It dawned on me that Henry was incredibly smart and got good grades, but he wasn’t exactly the goody-two-shoes that I was.
A different night during this surprise visit in Arizona, we went out driving, listening to his music. We ended up at a spot called Dump Park later in the evening. Sitting on a picnic table under the stars, with no one else around, I told him in not so many words that sometimes I wasn’t sure if I wanted to live anymore. He was my person, and even though it was painful, it felt safe to tell him the truth. He wasn’t happy to hear this, of course. He didn’t want me to be suffering. He also struggled with the impossibility that both him making me happy and me not wanting to live could be true. When we drove away, I was distracted by how upset our conversation was making us. I wanted to not feel depressed and yet also wanted to tell him, my best friend, the truth. We almost got into a car accident, my car almost drifting into the other lane, which also made me feel horrible. He was upset about the driving — understandably so — and I felt even worse that I’d put his life at risk. It was a crumbly mess. I couldn’t do anything right.
From that surprise visit, we still had that photo of us swing dancing. I got it printed and framed for my college dorm room. It was an undoubtedly hard summer so far, but we would be less sad someday when we lived together, when we could dance in our kitchen every night under soft lighting, with the future dogs we’d already named. Separating at the airport was difficult and tearful, and then he was gone. But we’d be close very soon, the miles between us about to be smooshed like an accordion. And we intended to see a lot more of each other.
* * *
As September approached, I happily busied myself getting ready for college. I bought my first winter coat, set up my University of Michigan email, purchased season football tickets, messaged my new college roommate on Facebook, and perused the course catalog. Picking a college had been difficult, but I was happy about where I was headed.
To Henry’s credit, we made a pact early into our relationship that we would keep college applications secret from one another. Afraid that I might turn down a great opportunity in favor of attending school with or near him, the pact had been my idea. I was kind of a feminist, remember? I knew the lure of him would be too tempting for me, and I wanted to put my education first. Thankfully, I’d decided this when we first started dating in September; I wasn’t sure I’d’ve been able to hold the same boundaries by this point in our relationship.
I knew he had applied to some schools in California and some in the midwest, and that was it. I didn’t even know which schools. I turned down two California schools myself, and I was worried that Henry would be relocating to the west coast just as I was leaving it.
I chose Michigan proudly. I loved that it was a big school with lots of spirit. I loved the brick buildings, the ivy, the town of Ann Arbor so interwoven with campus, and I loved the midwest. Embarrassingly, I loved that it was where the students who put on A Very Potter Musical had gone to college. Deep down, I also hoped that I would be moving closer, not further, from the love of my life.
My Spanish teacher, Señora Hayes, actually pulled me into the hallway during class when she found out I’d chosen to go to Michigan. She scolded me for following a boy to college, especially when she found out I’d turned down a really good in-state scholarship. I insisted that I wasn’t following my boyfriend, that this wasn’t about him, he wasn’t even going to Michigan, even though perhaps a portion of it was. There was a real gleam in her eyes that day.
Part of college prep was attending orientation. Orientation was in-person, so my mom and I flew to Ann Arbor in early August. Once Henry found out where I was going, he never hesitated to voice his surprise that I had chosen a “party school,” a “football school,” while he chose a superior small liberal arts college. He never acknowledged that U of M was the number one public school in the nation, or how many of its departments ranked first nationwide. Eventually, he’d float the idea of me transferring to his college.
Regardless of his opinion, I was excited and happy to be in Ann Arbor, and it was an important weekend for getting acclimated and meeting potential friends before I moved across the country. Naturally, I was texting Henry throughout. I apologized to a girl I had met who offered to walk around downtown with me; we were in an Urban Outfitters, and I had to tell her that my boyfriend and I were having some issues and that’s why I was texting so much. I knew I was being rude, and unlike my high school friends who knew the situation, this new friend didn’t know why I was so glued to my cell.
On the last morning of orientation, Henry dropped a seemingly random, hypothetical question. He asked over text out of the blue, “Would you still date me if I was a woman?”
I hesitated. I answered in a way that I thought was fair and kind and honest. I told him that if he transitioned to being a woman, I would try my best to date him/them throughout, and would certainly support the decision unconditionally, but it might be a little strange for me and I couldn’t promise anything, since I wasn’t attracted to women at the time.
More than hurt, Henry was devastated. He needed consoling and reassurance. He needed time to process what I’d said, since he thought I loved him unconditionally. He retreated, walls up, immediate silent treatment. I remember panicking, drying my tears in the communal dormitory bathroom where I was supposed to be making acquaintances and getting excited about college. I sat out of the rest of the activities for the day, and I was a sad sack with my mom for the rest of our travels. I felt empty, stupid, selfish, and unloving. I genuinely questioned my allyship to the LGBTQ community, which I had previously been very proud of and outspoken about.
Henry made me feel like a horrible person. It felt like a setup. It felt like he was making such a big deal out of a hypothetical. My answer had been truthful. Didn’t I owe him, my partner, the dignity of the truth?
His tantrums seemed choreographed. I was distraught. This would take so much undoing, but it could be done. After I learned my lesson.
It was all going to work out, though. It had to. We’d gotten this far, hadn’t we? We were in so deep, had invested so much time into the relationship. There was no one else. Despite our agreement to keep our college choices a secret, we did discover that our schools were both in the midwest. The thirty-one hours of distance would be shrinking to just ten. We’d both be away from our parents and have the freedom to stay up late, to talk, to visit each other. We were soulmates, and things had been rocky, but everything was about to change for the better. I knew, like always, that he would eventually forgive me. I just knew now that if he asked, “Would I still date him if…,” the answer was always yes.
That’s unconditional love.
* * *






