I knocked on Tony’s front door early Saturday evening, my white math binder clutched to my chest, and Henry came to greet me.
I’d spent all day on math homework, and when Henry texted to invite me to the party, I still had a few trigonometry problems I couldn’t crack. I told him I’d love to come, then, embracing my inner nerd, asked if I could come early with my math materials and enlist his help for the last few problems.
Henry led me upstairs to a bonus room, where we settled on the floor to tackle my math woes. We worked through problem after problem as the room slowly filled with people. Then Henry’s friend Parker wandered over and asked if we’d gotten back together.
“No, absolutely not,” I scoffed, the response spilling out so fast it felt almost knee-jerk. Henry shot me a sidelong glance.
“Ouch,” he said. I stared at him, incredulous. I thought we were on the same page about this. I wondered for a moment if he had the same takeaways as I did from our past relationship. I assumed he did, given that we had all the same information. I figured if he had even half the brains he claimed then he should know we didn’t work as a couple.
Parker wandered off, presumably in search of a more interesting conversation, and Henry went back to helping me with my math. I still wasn’t getting it. When I asked him to explain it for a second or third time, he… laughed.
Unacceptable. He didn’t get to laugh at me. This wasn’t the new us. It was like he was offended that I didn’t want to be his girlfriend, so now he wanted to knock me down a peg. Remind me of my place in the hierarchy. This was exactly the kind of shit I used to take from him, and I flat out refused to tolerate it now.
“Henry,” I said, looking at him sternly, “if I already knew how to do it, I wouldn’t be asking you for help!” My voice had grown loud by the end, and Henry’s wry smile vanished. He backpedaled and went back to explaining the math the way I’d asked.
I’d stood up to him, and he’d listened. This was huge. I wasn’t going to let him make me feel small anymore, even if he tried.
Soon the music was loud, drinks were being poured, and it no longer felt right to be sitting on the floor doing math. I set my binder aside as Henry mixed us a couple of drinks.
As the night at Tony’s unfolded, Parker, having learned I was single, began to show interest in me. He was a nice guy from what I knew, and I thought he was cute, so when he made his move, I kissed him back. Later, we were dancing drunkenly in the bonus room, now dark except for a strobe light, when Henry swooped in behind me, pulled me away from Parker by my hips, and held me against him instead.
Henry seemed jealous — that was interesting. By his own admission, he was hooking up with multiple other girls, and we were very decidedly not together. My earlier comment must’ve really stung to make him act like this.
I didn’t make a scene, but I pulled myself away from him. This was something I’d been learning since we were fifteen: a “yes” yesterday is not a “yes” today. Just because I wanted to make out with him in his car a few weeks ago, it did not mean that I wanted to make out with him tonight. It was well within my rights to say no, and I loved saying it to Henry in particular. What I didn’t love, however, was how he seemed to feel entitled to my attention. I needed him to know that he wasn’t.
When I pulled away from him, he did seem to get the hint that I really wasn’t interested tonight, and instead went off somewhere with his friend Leah. Later in the night I tailed the two of them into a bedroom (fueled by a morbid curiosity, probably), but only stayed for a moment before making the awkward realization out loud:
“Wait, why do I feel like I’m cockblocking?”
I was met with an uncomfortable silence from both of them.
It did strike me how quickly he went off to someone else once I expressed my disinterest, but I also supposed I’d rather he do that than continue to pursue me. And he was a known flirt, so this was kind of the name of the game. But still, it did make me feel like Leah and I, and maybe every other girl there, were interchangeable to him. I hoped that wasn’t true.
But despite the strange pang of bitterness I felt when I saw how he ran straight to Leah, I really appreciated how he respected my implicit “no” earlier. I didn’t even have to say it out loud. I just moved away from him, and he could read that I wasn’t into it and moved on.
It wasn’t always like that between us.
When Henry and I were dating at fifteen, I don’t think either of us had a solid understanding of what consent was. I at least didn’t. We liked to wrestle on the floor in his living room, with him always pinning me down in various positions since I had no idea how to wrestle and he was much stronger than me. He’d pin me down and ask me to try to get up, and obviously I never could, and we’d joke about how easily someone would be able to rape me. But of course, we were just kidding around. I’d usually just kind of laugh and say something like, “Dang, I’d be in trouble.” It was funny, we were joking.
Henry made it known pretty early on that he was interested in trying a few kinks. Nothing too far out of left field as far as kinks go. He wanted to try things like choking, using blindfolds, tying me up. These were all acts that were well out of my comfort zone, but I did my best to keep up with him.
One evening, as we lay together on his living room couch, he expressed his desire to have anal sex. This was something that I had absolutely no interest in. I told him, point blank, I would not do that.
He was mad at my response. He wanted to know how I could withhold this experience from him if I really, truly loved him. That angle worked for him sometimes, but it sure wasn’t enough right now — I still flat out refused. He told me he was going to convince me, and we started to argue.
I stood my ground. He wanted to know why I wouldn’t do it, and I just kept telling him that, simply, I didn’t want to. Honestly it just sounded scary and maybe painful and also kind of gross to me, so much so that I didn’t even feel comfortable voicing the intricacies of what exactly seemed unappealing.
“Actually… we’re going to do it right now.”
My heart dropped into my stomach, and my arguing quickly slipped into pleading.
“No, Henry, NO — please don’t, I don’t want to.” I knew he was much stronger than me. He pulled at the waistband of my pants and I started to cry.
And not a soft, hiccuping cry. It was more like an unblinking, eyes-wide-in-disbelief kind of cry. An I-can’t-believe-you-would-do-this-to-me kind of cry.
He calmly turned me to face away from him in that detached position he liked and pulled out his already erect dick, seemingly unmoved by my distress.
I said “please” one more time, then shut my eyes tight, preparing. I knew I would break up with him over this. Even with my juvenile understanding of consent, I knew this was too far. If he went through with this there would be no coming back from it. I said NO.
Then, with the side of my face pressed into the couch pillows, he pulled himself against me and whispered in my ear,
“Shannon, you’re crying. I’m not going to have anal sex with you while you’re crying. But someday, we will do it.”
Then, suddenly, he thrust forward — penetrating my stunned body vaginally. I inhaled sharply, shocked. His thrusts shook any stagnant tears out of my eyes and sent them rolling down my face.
I didn’t know how to feel. I lay motionless and waited for it to be over.
Did he just rape me? I thought he was about to, but then… he didn’t? I wasn’t sure. I mean, technically I said “no” to a different type of sex… and also I didn’t scream. Weren’t girls supposed to scream? His mom was in the house, help could’ve been right there if I really wanted it. It seemed wrong that I was scared and crying… but honestly that wasn’t the first time we’d had sex while I was crying and I didn’t think of it as rape those times.
Not to mention, I’d need to break up with him if I actually thought that’s what he did, and I really didn’t want to break up with him. More than anything, I just wanted him to love me. I wouldn’t end things with him unless I was absolutely sure it was what needed to be done.
So I decided that he didn’t do anything wrong. I was just a little startled — that’s all! I decided I was okay and it was okay and I could keep dating him.
It was as simple, and cruel, as that.
Yet, I left his house that evening with an ache in my chest and a hollowness in my core that I struggle to describe. I felt as if I was caving in on myself. I felt like shed snakeskin, used and cast aside. Dead and lifeless. Spineless. Empty.
Looking back, it’s no mystery why I chose to believe the story I did. I’d been trained for it.
At fifteen, my (Catholic) sex education up to that point went something like this: premarital sex = eternal damnation. The narrative was succinct: don’t ask about it, don’t do it — the end. My parents once even enrolled me in an all-day retreat at our church to promote abstinence to teenagers. At this camp, they had us young teens hold bricks above our heads to symbolize the fight that we needed to put up to keep ourselves pure. They taught us that it wouldn’t always be easy, but God’s love would be worth it. Because once you’ve had sex, you’ve failed. You’re damned. You’ve made your bed and now you have to sleep in it, sinner.
But still, when my parents met Henry, they approved of him immediately. He was handsome, an obvious athlete, well-mannered, and raised in a good Christian household. The first time he came to my house he let my little sisters paint all over his face and arms, and from then on they adored him. He let them climb on him and pose with him as my mom took pictures, and I jumped on his back at one point too, wrapping my arms around his chest. My mom snapped a picture of us smiling ear to ear and covered in paint. My mom, my sisters, and I collectively thought that this was the beginning of something beautiful.
Then as our relationship progressed, something about our dynamic wasn’t feeling right, but I didn’t know how to explain it. And I didn’t feel like I had anyone I could ask about it. Most of my friends didn’t have boyfriends, and the ones who did certainly weren’t having sex. And, of course, I couldn’t talk to my parents. My Catholic parents. Who’d just sent me to a church retreat promoting abstinence.
At that retreat I was also surprised to learn from my church leaders that even non-consensual sex counted as sex in the eyes of God. A kid actually asked that — the question was: does it count as losing your virginity if you’re raped? The speaker clicked his tongue and paused for a moment before saying that it would be unfortunate… but yes, to God it would still count.
I was horrified to learn that women would still be ruined even if we didn’t mean to, didn’t want to, didn’t enjoy it. Then I did it willingly, and I was ruined all the same. This wasn’t the image of me that my parents had in their heads, the sweet daughter they’d raised. I couldn’t tell them about this. All this gray-area sex was starting to make me feel like I was crumbling, slowly losing pieces of myself, but I resolved to believe that I deserved all the pain that was coming for me. I shouldn’t have been having sex in the first place. This hollow feeling was my punishment. This was all my fault.
I did eventually tell some girls at school that Henry and I were having sex. All I said was that we were doing “it,” graciously sparing them the ugly details. I don’t remember how he found out I told — if he heard it from someone else, or if I was even the one who told him. But my God, he was enraged. That was a new level of anger for him. One that led to weeks’ worth of silent treatments and ended with me writing pages-long apologies in notebooks begging for his forgiveness. Because I hadn’t just blown our secret — I defamed myself. Now I was a whore. At least, that’s how he told me our classmates saw me.
He wanted to break up over this, actually. Couldn’t I see how embarrassing this was for him? How bad it looked for him to be dating someone like me? He didn’t know if he could be seen with me anymore.
But I didn’t want to break up. A big part of the reason I agreed to have sex with him in the first place was that he told me we’d get married someday. By senior year I knew how unlikely it was that high school sweethearts actually stayed together, but as a freshman and sophomore I really thought it was possible, and I clung to that idea.
He did forgive me for telling, eventually. But I was on thin ice, so I was being more passive, more tolerant than ever. I was worried about how far he might push that.
I began to grow nervous as we approached our sixteenth birthdays. We’d be getting driver’s licenses soon, and that meant he was about to have a whole new level of access to me. The car would be a secluded place where no one would be around to hear us argue, see me cry, make him second-guess raising his voice. He was eagerly looking forward to car sex. I didn’t know how to tell him that I was dreading it.
But now it was senior year, we were eighteen, and everything was different. I could put him in his place when necessary, and I didn’t care if he got mad at me in return. If he couldn’t treat me with respect, then I didn’t need him, and I had long since made my peace with that. I was more than happy to say “no” — this was my redemption arc.
Cue the montage. Piano duets. Hallway conversations in Spanish while our teacher beamed at the two of us like proud parents. A Spanish project at my house that somehow turned into Henry chatting with my dad for half an hour. An Asian buffet after a grueling dinner shift, where I teased him for loading his plate with nothing but Jell-O and other American food. We were spending more and more time together as the year wound down, and we weren’t hiding it.
The montage peaked on the day of the senior boys’ pageant, a mostly comical show he’d entered, with me cast as his “escort.” That afternoon I went to his house with my chemistry lab report, and he corrected it with total confidence before I settled in to listen to him rehearse an acoustic “Suit & Tie” for the talent portion. It wasn’t until I submitted the lab report with his corrections that I learned he’d never even taken chemistry in high school. He really was just that smart.
That evening I walked onstage in a long black dress during his introduction, stood next to him in the heat of the stage lights, then he scooped me up and carried me off like I weighed nothing.
Then… starting in the spring of our senior year, Henry and I started to do more than just make out. Not every time we met up, but… sometimes.
Though I had distanced myself decently from the Catholic purity culture I grew up around, those ties still hadn’t been cut completely. As an eighteen-year-old, I didn’t feel quite so ostracized for being a non-virgin like I did a few years prior, but there were limits to my liberation. I still didn’t want the overall number of people I slept with to get too high. Even the most sex-positive girl I knew, a friend I ran track with, once said she wanted to keep her body count under ten by the time she found her forever person. This was a number that would say something about me — was I a “party girl” or “wife material”? And I didn’t want to get close to a new guy in my hometown that I could accidentally develop a crush on right before college. That almost felt like I’d be shooting myself in the foot.
So I was in the market for a hookup, and Henry just made sense. I was physically attracted to him, and I had an ironclad reason never to date him. And the added bonus: he wouldn’t add to my body count? Perfect. I’d learned that math when I was fourteen, holding a brick above my head.
We didn’t do this often. Maybe once or twice in the spring and then one more time early in the summer. You have to remember, I still loved telling him no. Probably more than having sex with him. So sneaking him into my room one weekend and then not even kissing him the next gave me a sense of empowerment I’d been craving for years.
There was one strange wrinkle in the fabric of our friendship, though. I normally wasn’t too active on social media, but at the end of the school year I came across Henry’s Facebook page and noticed that his profile picture was of a girl with blonde, curly hair kissing his cheek. Odd. I clicked to see who she was, and then saw that they were listed as “in a relationship”… even more odd. But then I saw she lived in Arizona, and immediately waved it aside.
This was probably just a girl he met at some group for other high school brainiacs, and this was them being a little flirty. Just like how he was with that girl Carly in Youth in Government our freshman year. He had been telling me about the girls on his roster since we started hanging out in November, and the name “Rachel” hadn’t come up even once. Our friendship had been platonic until the spring, he would’ve told me months ago if there was someone he was considering dating seriously.
Plus I had been over to his house and spoken with his parents multiple times — would he really have let his mother see him spend time with his ex-girlfriend like that if he had a current, serious girlfriend? Would he let our whole senior class see him pick me up on stage at that competition? Let his friends see him make out with girls at parties? There was just no world where this was a real girlfriend. She lived across the country, and they had like two pictures together. This was obviously some kind of inside joke he had with this girl. I mean, he was a flirt — he did things like that.
In June 2014 we graduated, leaving behind the only world either of us had ever known. Senior summer was notoriously supposed to be one of the wildest of our lives, and for once the hype was accurate. My friends and his started drifting together until we were one big, loud group, and I finally felt connected to the people I’d lost touch with.
Telling those friends how much time I was spending with Henry felt a little like admitting to a relapse. They knew how ugly things had been between us a couple of years earlier. But he had been there for me when they weren’t, and we were together so often that there was no point denying it. We were friends now. Obviously.
My parents spent most summer weekends out of town, and I stayed behind to waitress the busiest days of the week at a restaurant in downtown Green Bay. One weekend I was only on lunch shifts, which left my evenings free, and a house party was happening in town with half our former classmates invited. Henry and I decided to go.
He came over while I got ready, sprawled across my bed on his phone while I straightened my hair and did my makeup. I modeled a couple of outfits and asked what he thought. He barely looked up.
That was typical of our newfound friendship, and I took it as proof that he was a different person now. He didn’t care what I wore.
We drove the party together in his car. Henry was a confident driver, but he didn’t necessarily follow the laws of the road. He texted while driving almost constantly. He’d send Snapchats. He’d make illegal turns. He drove as fast as he pleased, regardless of the posted speed limit. It was almost like he felt that driving was beneath him, like it was entirely too easy. But what was most strange to me was that even though he behaved this way, I didn’t actually feel like he was a bad driver. It was like other people, normal people, needed traffic laws to be safe, but not him. But also his actions never seemed careless — instead, they were calculated. I was always a bit nervous, but I was also in awe.
We parked down the street so we’d be less conspicuous, and then once inside, we split up almost immediately. Me to beer pong, him to flip cup with his friends. But every so often our eyes would meet across the room, a silent You good? He was my person at this party, my home base.
We hadn’t been there long when red and blue lights started sweeping across the windows.
The music cut out. The lights went off. A houseful of drunk recent grads began whispering escape plans all at once. Should we run? Hide? Try to rescue the people puking in the bathrooms, or write them off as a lost cause?
I already knew my strategy: find Henry. If anyone could get me out of this unscathed, it was him. He was the smartest person I knew, and I’d have bet good money he could talk his way out of a sticky encounter with the police, drunk or not, on educated white-boy charm alone.
He slipped us into the garage, and we crouched behind a large SUV. “I will get us out of here,” he said. “We are not going to get caught.”
I believed him completely.
There was a small window in the garage, and he kept peeking out at the road, then reporting back to the people waiting fearfully inside the house, like a general briefing a very drunk army. The police never came in, at least not while we were there. Finally, he found a moment when the coast was clear.
He crouched beside me again. “Okay, Shannon. We’re going to make a run for it. The goal is to make it to the car, but if we’re being chased, keep running through yards. I cannot get caught, so I will not stop running. If you stop, I can’t help you.”
I nodded. My heart was going so hard I could feel it in my teeth.
We made a beeline for the door, speed walking, eyes down, avoiding everyone else’s. The second we stepped outside, our strides turned into a sprint. We tore across manicured lawns and across the street, dodging streetlights. He was fast. I ran a couple of yards behind him, eyes on his back the whole way. No one followed.
Three hundred yards later, we reached the car and shut ourselves inside. For a moment neither of us spoke. The adrenaline had sobered us up, and after the noise of the house the quiet felt strange, just the two of us, breathing hard.
He didn’t start the car. He turned his whole body to face me in the passenger seat, leaned in… and kissed me.
It caught me off guard. Despite our occasional hookups since spring, we’d kept a clear line between sex and everything else. When we hung out, we hung out. On the few nights I snuck him into my room, there was no cuddling and no pillow talk. It always felt pretty transactional, if I’m being honest, and I was okay with that. He’d come over, we’d have sex, and he’d leave. Those were the terms.
But this kiss wasn’t in the contract. His lips met mine gently and lingered a moment before he pulled back. I felt a hint of affection that didn’t belong to our relationship as I knew it. Maybe he cared about me more than I thought he did. Maybe I wasn’t just a friend or just a hookup to him, but someone special. Maybe that was the moment I finally lowered my guard and let myself believe I could trust him.
Then he started the car, and neither of us ever brought it up again.





